Necessary Lies by, Diane Chamberlain narrated by, Alison
Elliott
Another fascinating book about the eugenics program in North
Carolina this time told from the perspective of a new social worker who is appalled
at the program. The first book I read on this subject was “Unfit by, LaraCleveland Torgesen” which I found fascinating and I think both of these books
should be read to really get a feel for what these poor women/young
ladies/children went through.
Jane may be a woman ahead of her time because the only
respectable job for a lady was a school teacher or nurse especially when you
are married to a pediatrician who really doesn’t want you to work. You surely
don’t go to work as a social worker, working with the poor and god forbid the
coloreds , it made me sick that her husband was more upset about her having to
work with the coloreds and that she wasn’t there to have dinner waiting for
him. I for one am so glad at how far we have come as women!
We also meet Ivy Hart who is one of Jane’s clients Ivy is
trying to keep her little family together even though she is only 15 years old
herself. She takes care of her grandmother who has a problem with sugar which
we now call diabetes and an older sister who has already had one illegitimate
child but little William is the apple of everyone’s eye and they do try their
best to take good care of him. But when Jane takes over as case worker
everything changes, Jane makes a discovery and tells a secret that changes
everything for the Hart family.
I really liked this book, this was a new to me author and
narrator and I enjoyed them both very much. I liked the authors writing style
and I found the subject matter well handled. The characters in this book are nicely
fleshed out and it gives us a frightening look into social work in the 1960’s
in North Carolina, which was the one state that continued the eugenics program
longer than any other state, so many women (and men) were sterilized just for being
poor or colored, which I feel is horrifying.
Narrator Alison Elliott did a really good job at portraying
both of these women and I thought she added to the telling of this story I will
definitely listen to her again.
I will be looking for other books by this author.
4 ½ Stars